Gutter Contractors in Nashville: 8 Questions to Ask First
Nashville has more gutter contractors than it did five years ago, for the same reason it has more of everything: the houses. A lot of the new Nashville gutter installation contractors are fine. Some are a truck, a borrowed coil machine and a Facebook page. The questions below take about five minutes on the phone and sort one from the other before anyone comes out.
The eight questions
1. Are you insured, and will you send the certificate?
General liability covers your house if a ladder goes through a window. Workers' compensation covers the person on the ladder if they fall, so that you aren't the one being sued. Ask for both, and ask for the certificate to be emailed before the crew arrives, not shown on a phone in the driveway. A contractor who hesitates on this one has answered the question.
2. Does this job need a Tennessee license, and do you have it?
Tennessee licenses contractors by job size, and the home improvement license applies only in some counties (Davidson is one). The current thresholds, and whether a given job needs a license, are questions for the Tennessee Board for Licensing Contractors and Metro Codes — check with them rather than relying on anyone's rule of thumb, including this guide's. You can look up a contractor's license on the state's license search or at verify.tn.gov. Also ask for a certificate of liability insurance sent by their agent. Either way, ask; a contractor who knows the rules will answer without fumbling.
3. What gauge aluminum, and what hangers?
The right answers are .032 coil and hidden screw hangers every 24 inches. The wrong answers are .027, spike and ferrule, or a pause while they think about it. The gauge and the hangers are the two biggest differences between a gutter that lasts 25 years and one that sags in eight, and the price difference between them on a whole house is under $250. What the price per foot buys goes through both.
4. How are you sizing the downspouts?
You want to hear something about roof area, and you want to hear 3x4. A contractor who defaults to 2x3 downspouts, one per run, is quoting a system that will overflow at the far corner in the first spring storm. Ask how many downspouts they're putting on the longest run, and if the answer is one and the run is over 35 feet, ask why.
5. Will you check the fascia, and what does it cost per foot if it's bad?
The board behind the gutter is where old Nashville gutters hide their problems. A contractor who quotes from the driveway and finds soft fascia on install day either hangs the new gutter on rot or hands you a surprise. The right answer is that they check it with a screwdriver from the ladder during the estimate, and the quote lists a per-foot price for replacement in case some is found.
6. What's the warranty, in writing, and who backs it?
Two parts. The aluminum finish is warranted by the manufacturer, typically 20 years or more against fading and peeling; that comes with the coil regardless of who installs it. The workmanship — leaks at the corners, pitch, hangers pulling loose — is the contractor's. One to five years is the range and two is common; get it in writing. A "lifetime" warranty from a company that started last spring is worth what the company is.
7. Can I see a job you did two years ago?
Not a photo from last week. A gutter looks good the day it's hung. Ask for an address, or a name you can call, on a job that's been through two springs. A contractor who has been in Nashville a while has a dozen of those. One who hasn't will offer references from last month, which tell you about their manners and nothing about their hangers.
8. Is the estimate written, itemized, and good for how long?
The estimate should list, as separate lines:
- Gutter size and aluminum gauge
- Hanger type and spacing
- Downspout size and count, per run
- Corners
- Fascia replacement per foot, in case any is found
- Guards per foot, if any
- Tear-off, haul-away and extensions
It should be free. It should be good for 30 days. A number on a business card, or a price that drops if you sign today, is a sales technique, not a quote. The cost page shows what the lines should look like.
The questions that don't help
How long have you been in business? Everyone rounds up. The two-year-old job reference is the real version of this question.
Are you the cheapest? The cheapest quote on a Nashville house is nearly always .027 coil, spike hangers and 2x3 downspouts, which is the gutter you're replacing. Repair vs. replacement covers when cheap is actually the right call: when the fix is a $200 reseal and someone's trying to sell you new gutters.
Do you have a lot of five-star reviews? A good small crew may have only a handful, and a weak one may have hundreds. Reviews tell you about the sales process more than the hangers.
Where this site fits
This site is a free guide for Nashville homeowners, not a gutter contractor. Estimate requests go to an independent local contractor partner who performs the work. Whoever comes out, ask them the same eight questions, whether it's a seamless gutter contractor for one long run or a crew quoting the whole house, and compare the answers. The about page explains how a request works.
Red flags during the visit
- A price before anyone climbs a ladder
- A "today only" discount
- A large cash deposit before the coil is ordered
- No written estimate, or one with a single total and no lines
- Pressure to sign an insurance assignment after a storm
- An offer to cover your deductible
Any one of these is a reason to slow down and get another estimate.
How to compare the answers
Write each contractor's answers to the eight questions in a simple table: one column per contractor, one row per question. Then look at the totals. The gaps usually line up with the answers. A lower price often comes with .027 coil, wider hanger spacing, fewer downspouts or no fascia line. A higher one should come with better answers, not just a bigger number. If two quotes give the same answers, the lower one may simply be the better deal.
After you hire
Get the start date and the payment terms in writing. On the day, ask the crew to point out any fascia they replaced before the new gutters cover it. Before they leave, ask for a hose test with you watching. Keep the estimate, the invoice and the warranty together. If something leaks in the first year, those papers make the callback simple, and they help when you sell the house.
Common questions
How many gutter contractors should I get quotes from?
Two or three for a full replacement or a guard install. One clear, itemized quote is often enough for a small repair. More than three usually adds confusion rather than useful information.
Should I pay a deposit for gutter installation?
Some contractors ask for one to order coil in a special color; others collect at completion on a one-day job. Ask before you sign, get the terms in writing, and be wary of a large cash deposit up front.
What if a contractor won't answer one of the questions?
Ask once more, plainly. Some people are just bad on the phone. But a contractor who won't say what gauge or hangers they use, or won't put the price in writing, is telling you how the job will go.
Do I need a written contract for a small gutter repair?
A written estimate that names the work and the price is enough for most small repairs. For a full replacement or a guard install, get a written contract or a signed estimate that covers scope, price, payment terms, start date and the warranty.
Need gutter work in Nashville?
Call for a free estimate. Mon–Sat 7am–7pm.